# Rebuild or sell after a wildfire? The 3 paths compared

After a wildfire destroys your house, California law gives you 3 paths. You can rebuild on your lot, replace the house somewhere else or sell the lot without replacing it. On either of the first 2 paths, you can collect the full replacement cost your policy covers. If you sell without replacing, you generally get the actual cash value, which is less.

By Highkey staff. Published 2026-11-17. Comparison, Aftermath.

Canonical: https://highkeyinsured.com/aftermath/rebuild-or-sell-after-wildfire/

## The short version

- After a total loss, you can rebuild, replace the house elsewhere or sell the lot without replacing it.
- If you replace the house elsewhere, the insurer pays up to what rebuilding at the old address would cost, without deducting the new land's value.
- After a declared emergency, you have at least 36 months from the insurer's first payment to collect the full replacement cost.
- Before you choose, get a licensed contractor's estimate of rebuilding your old house, then ask your insurer in writing what it will pay on each path.

## What are the 3 paths after a total loss?

The 3 paths are rebuilding on your lot, replacing the house somewhere else and selling without replacing. Each one changes what the insurer pays, what your lender does and what you owe in property tax.

The California Department of Insurance's tips for wildfire claimants say "you can purchase or rebuild at another location, and still receive full replacement cost benefits." Replacing elsewhere includes buying a house that's already built.

Here's how the 3 paths compare under California law, for a home lost in a disaster the Governor declared:

| | Rebuild on your lot | Buy or build elsewhere | Sell the lot and don't replace |
|---|---|---|---|
| What the insurer pays for the house | Replacement cost, up to your limits, as you rebuild | Up to what rebuilding at the old address would cost, with no deduction for the new land | Generally the actual cash value, which is rebuild cost minus depreciation |
| Extended replacement cost and code upgrades | Paid if your policy has them | Paid if your policy has them, figured on the old address | Not covered by the rebuild elsewhere rule, so ask your insurer in writing |
| Time to collect the full amount | At least 36 months from the first payment | At least 36 months from the first payment | Doesn't apply unless you replace within that time |
| Living expenses | Paid while you rebuild, within your limit | Generally end when you move into the replacement | Generally end when you find permanent housing |
| Property tax | Your old tax base comes back if you rebuild a comparable house in time | Your old tax base can move with you under 3 different rules | You can still move your tax base under Prop 19 if you buy within 2 years of the sale |

## What does the insurer pay on each path?

On a replacement cost policy, you collect the full replacement cost on the first 2 paths. On the third, you generally collect the actual cash value.

### Rebuilding on your lot

Insurance Code section 2051.5 defines replacement cost as the cost to repair, rebuild or replace "without a deduction for physical depreciation," up to your limit. A policy can require you to rebuild before the insurer pays in full. Until then, the insurer pays the actual cash value and holds back the rest.

If your dwelling limit won't cover the rebuild, the law gives you one more source of money. After a declared emergency, section 10103.7 lets you combine your dwelling and other structures limits to rebuild the house. The Department of Insurance repeated that rule in Bulletin 2025-2, which it sent to insurers on January 23, 2025.

### Buying or building elsewhere

Section 2051.5(c) says a policy can't limit or refuse replacement cost or code upgrade coverage after a total loss because you rebuild or buy at a new location. The payment is capped at what rebuilding at the original location would cost, including code upgrades and any extended replacement cost.

The insurer can't subtract the value of the land at the new location. So if a replacement house costs more partly because its lot is worth more, the insurer still pays up to the rebuild figure for your old house.

That rule matters because some adjusters said otherwise after the January 2025 fires. Bulletin 2025-2 says adjusters told some owners they'd lose code upgrade pay because those costs wouldn't be "incurred." Others told owners the new land's value would be deducted. The Department said both were wrong.

You generally can't buy a cheaper house and keep the rest. United Policyholders is a nonprofit that helps disaster survivors with claims. Its answer to that question is "Generally no, unless your insurer gives you a cash-out settlement with no strings attached."

### Selling without replacing

If you don't rebuild or buy, you generally get the actual cash value. United Policyholders says "the insurer pays only ACV until progress has been made toward replacing or repairing the asset."

Insurance Code section 2051 measures actual cash value as the cost to rebuild, minus a fair deduction for depreciation, up to your limit. The deduction applies only to parts of a house that are normally repaired or replaced during its useful life.

Selling the lot doesn't end your right to the full replacement cost by itself. If you sell and then buy a house within the time limit, you're on the second path.

## How long do you have to decide?

After a declared emergency, you have at least 36 months from the insurer's first actual cash value payment to collect the full replacement cost. Section 2051.5 also requires six-month extensions for good cause, such as permit delays or a shortage of materials or contractors.

The Department of Insurance tells survivors not to rush. Its tips list what to weigh, including your mortgage, your job, your finances, your age, your children's schools and how much construction trouble you can take. It adds that "few, if any, need to be made today."

### Living expenses

Living expense coverage pays the extra cost of living somewhere else while you can't live at home. After a declared emergency it lasts at least 24 months, plus up to 12 more for delays beyond your control. Your policy's dollar limit can run out first, the Department says.

The coverage generally stops sooner if you replace the house. A United Policyholders expert wrote that it "generally continues only as long as it takes to either rebuild or replace your home," or until you find permanent housing. So ask your insurer in writing when the payments would end before you sign for a new home.

### Your policy

If you rebuild, section 675.1 protects your current policy. It bars your insurer from cancelling the policy while the house is being rebuilt, except for the reasons listed in section 676. After a total loss in a disaster, the insurer must also offer at least 2 annual renewals, and no less than 24 months of coverage from the loss.

If you buy elsewhere, you'll need a new policy on the house you buy. Casa, whose team runs this site and quotes California home insurance, has [a list of what to check on a replacement house's insurance](https://casa.insure/learn/check-home-insurance-before-buying-california). It says to look up the home's fire hazard zone on CAL FIRE's map and check its claims history, roof and wiring. Then get a quote on the address before you make an offer, so you know who's willing to insure it before you commit to the second path.

## What happens to your mortgage?

You still owe the loan after the fire, whichever path you choose. Your lender's control over the insurance money for the house depends on your deed of trust.

California Civil Code section 2924.7 says a deed of trust can give the lender the right "to receive and control the disbursement" of fire insurance money. That's true even if the fire didn't put the loan at risk.

If you plan to buy elsewhere, ask your servicer in writing how it handles insurance money for a house at a new address. The servicer is the company you send your payments to.

If you plan to sell the lot, ask your lender in writing for a payoff demand statement first. Under Civil Code section 2943, that's the written total it takes to pay off the loan. The lender has 21 days to send it. Compare that number with what the lot and the insurance money would bring in.

## What happens to your property taxes?

You can lower the tax bill on the burned property now. Later, you can keep your old tax base whether you rebuild or buy another home. The rules come from the California State Board of Equalization's disaster relief guide, Publication 802 (May 2026).

First, file for a reassessment with your county assessor. If the damage was at least $10,000, the assessor lowers the property's value to reflect the damage until you rebuild. The deadline is 12 months from the loss, or longer if your county allows it. For the 2025 Palisades, Eaton, Hurst, Lidia, Sunset and Woodley fires and the 2024 Mountain and Franklin fires, it's 24 months.

### If you rebuild on your lot

You keep your old tax base if the new house is comparable to the old one. Under Revenue and Taxation Code section 70.5, the rebuilt house's market value can be up to 120% of the old one's. Value above that is added to your tax base.

You have 5 years from the disaster to rebuild. The window is 8 years for the 2018 Camp and Woolsey fires, the December 2024 Franklin Fire and the January 2025 Los Angeles fires listed above.

### If you buy or build elsewhere

There are 3 ways to take your old tax base to a new home:

- **Same county (section 69).** You have 5 years from the disaster. Value above 120% of the old home's value is taxed at market value. You don't have to sell the burned property.
- **Another county that accepts transfers (section 69.3).** As of May 2026, 14 counties accept them, including Los Angeles, Orange, San Diego, Santa Clara, Sonoma and Ventura. You have 3 years from the disaster. The new home's value limit is 105%, 110% or 115% of the old one's, depending on the year you buy.
- **Any county (section 69.6, Prop 19).** You must sell the burned property in its damaged state and buy or build the new home within 2 years of the sale.

Publication 802 says you can't use a transfer and also keep your old tax base on the burned lot if you rebuild it.

The Board's Prop 19 page gives an example. An owner's burned home was worth $400,000 before the fire, with a tax base of $100,000. In the first year after selling, the owner buys a $600,000 home. The threshold for that year is 105% of $400,000, which is $420,000. The $180,000 above that is added, so the new tax base is $280,000.

### If you sell and don't replace

Your Prop 19 window stays open for 2 years after the sale, so you can still move your tax base if you buy a home within that time.

## What else changes with each path?

Debris removal and income tax both work a little differently on each path.

### Debris removal

After a large fire, the state and county may run a cleanup that collects only your insurance money set aside for debris. The Department of Insurance wrote to insurers about the program after the 2025 Los Angeles fires. It said the program's benefits apply "even if the policyholder decides not to rebuild in the same location but rebuilds or purchases a replacement home in another location."

If your debris coverage is part of your dwelling limit, the county could collect only what was left unused "after the residence is completely rebuilt." The Department's notice doesn't say how that works if you sell and don't replace. Ask your county and your insurer in writing before you list the lot.

### Income tax

The IRS treats a destroyed main home much like a sale. Publication 547 says "you can generally exclude the gain from your income as if you had sold or exchanged your home." The exclusion is up to $250,000, or $500,000 for a married couple filing jointly, if you generally owned and lived in the home 2 of the last 5 years.

You can also put off tax on a gain by buying a replacement. For a main home in a federally declared disaster area, the IRS gives you until 4 years after the end of the first tax year with a gain. Ask a tax professional how these rules apply to you before you sell the lot.

## How do you choose?

Work out what each path pays before you pick one. These steps follow the Department of Insurance's tips and United Policyholders' advice:

1. Ask your insurer for a full copy of your policy. The Department says it must send one free within 30 days of your request.
2. Get at least one licensed contractor's estimate to rebuild your old house as it was. The Department warns that insurer estimates "may contain errors or fail to reflect local conditions."
3. Ask your insurer in writing for its replacement cost figure for the old house, including extended replacement cost and code upgrades. If you buy or build elsewhere, the payment is capped at that figure.
4. Ask your servicer in writing how it releases money on each path, and ask for a payoff demand statement if you might sell.
5. Ask your county assessor which tax rule fits your plan, and file the reassessment claim now.
6. Weigh the rest: your job, your children's schools, your age and how long you can live somewhere temporary.

Put each answer in writing and keep copies. If you make an agreement with your insurer, get it in writing too.

## Questions people ask

**Can I sell my burned lot and still get the full insurance payout?**
Yes, if you buy or build a replacement home within the time limit. After a declared emergency that's at least 36 months from the insurer's first actual cash value payment. If you never replace the house, you generally get only the actual cash value.

**Can I buy a cheaper house and keep the rest of the money?**
Generally no. United Policyholders says the answer is no unless your insurer agrees to a cash-out settlement with no strings attached. The replacement cost is paid as you spend it, up to what rebuilding your old house would cost.

**Will my insurer deduct the value of the land at my new home?**
No. California Insurance Code section 2051.5(c) bars an insurer from deducting the value of the land at the new location. The Department of Insurance reminded insurers of that rule in Bulletin 2025-2, after some adjusters told owners otherwise.

**Do I lose code upgrade coverage if I don't rebuild at the same address?**
No. If you rebuild or buy elsewhere, section 2051.5(c) pays the code upgrade costs of rebuilding at the old address, if your policy has that coverage. The total is capped at what rebuilding there would cost.

**How long can I wait to decide?**
After a declared emergency, you have at least 36 months from the first actual cash value payment to collect the full replacement cost. Insurers must add six-month extensions for good cause. Your living expense coverage and your county's property tax deadlines may run on different clocks, so check each one.

## Sources

- California Insurance Code sections [2051](https://california.public.law/codes/ca_ins_code_section_2051), [2051.5](https://california.public.law/codes/ca_ins_code_section_2051.5) and [675.1](https://california.public.law/codes/ca_ins_code_section_675.1)
- California Department of Insurance, [Bulletin 2025-2](https://www.insurance.ca.gov/0250-insurers/0300-insurers/0200-bulletins/bulletin-notices-commiss-opinion/upload/Bulletin-2025-2-Wildfire-Consumer-Protections-and-Advanced-Payments.pdf), January 23, 2025
- California Department of Insurance, [Top Ten Tips for Wildfire Claimants](https://www.insurance.ca.gov/01-consumers/140-catastrophes/toptentips_wildfireclaimants.cfm)
- California Department of Insurance, [Notice on the 2025 Los Angeles Wildfires Consolidated Debris Removal Program](https://www.insurance.ca.gov/0250-insurers/0300-insurers/0200-bulletins/bulletin-notices-commiss-opinion/loader.cfm?csModule=security/getfile&PageID=352436), January 30, 2025
- United Policyholders, [Buy or Rebuild? FAQs on replacing a dwelling after a total loss](https://uphelp.org/claim-guidance-publications/buy-or-rebuild-faqs-on-replacing-a-dwelling-after-a-total-loss/)
- United Policyholders, [Ask an expert: ALE benefits while looking for replacement home](https://uphelp.org/ask-an-expert/question/ale-benefits-while-looking-for-replacement-home/)
- California Civil Code sections [2924.7](https://california.public.law/codes/civil_code_section_2924.7) and [2943](https://california.public.law/codes/civil_code_section_2943)
- California State Board of Equalization, [Publication 802, Information Guide for Disaster Relief for Damaged or Destroyed Property](https://boe.ca.gov/pdf/pub802.pdf) (5-26)
- California State Board of Equalization, [Proposition 19](https://www.boe.ca.gov/prop19/)
- IRS Publication 547 (2025), [Casualties, Disasters, and Thefts](https://www.irs.gov/publications/p547)
- Casa, Check Home Insurance Before an Offer in California

---

Run by the team behind Casa, a technology platform of SimpliSent, Inc.
